Chris Appy, a historian who has written about Vietnam, told HNN he once asked POW Porter Halyburton about the claims made against Fonda. officer gets an idea. The war was being fought by the air during during the Nixon administration. She has to be a murderess too. All were hired by Roger Ailes, the former network boss who exited in August 2016 amid a sexual harassment scandal. (Later, after 58,152 American dead were just names on a wall, declassified US Navy logs revealed there had been no torpedo attack!). In no sense am I a Fonda apologist. The great General Douglas MacArthur drove the North Koreans, led by Red Chinese Others were hoping to catch a glimpse of a famous Hollywood actress. She has to be a murderess too. Bates (private citizen), What do all you old sober sides make of this thesis? quote: Fonda was a political activist in the counterculture era during the Vietnam War. She was dubbed "Hanoi Jane" after traveling to the Communist capital. And I didnt even think and they sang me a song and Im made me laugh. Her lawsuit started it all: Former Fox host Gretchen Carlson claims Ailes repeatedly sexually harassed her. From Urban Legends: UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: How are you, G.I. After Fonda returned from hertrip, the State Department spoke out against her. Even so, the main focus of my essay was whether Jane Fonda participated in war crimes, not whether she was morally culpable for her part as an apologist for the mistreatment of POW's (she was). If a prisoner tried to escape, it is quite understandable that he would probably be beaten and tortured.. Truman warned Chiang to integrate communists into China's nationalist government or American aid would be withdrawn. The war was being fought by the air during during the Nixon administration. If you must know, my original draft did make reference to the one true story that you mentioned. Kelly was defending herself after Fonda said over the weekend that the question was so inappropriate and that Kelly is not that good an interviewer.. But she was advised by other activists to focus her political energies, deciding to go all-in as an impassioned voice for the antiwar movement. Its something very like the worst sort of lovers betrayal, the deep wound that time itself often is powerless to heal. Shewas active in the Black Panthers and marched for the rights of American Indians, soldiers and working mothers. Kelly responded with a cannon by bringing up the time Fonda posed on a North Vietnamese anti-aircraft gun. Urban Legends story then identifies the POW and gives some quotes about his treatment by the NVA. CHRIS WALLACE: Who the people in the Nixon administration? I remember one retired lieutenant colonel describing a conversation he had with an angry trooper about the treasonous behavior of Jane Fonda in the midst of the 1968 Tet Offensive. Did Jane Fonda Betray US POWs by Handing Over Hundreds of Americans had gone to North Vietnam, journalists diplomats, our Secretary of State Ramsey Clark, Vietnam veterans, but I said but a movie star hasnt gone and maybe if I go it will draw more attention, and thats what it did. Status: TRUE" Credit: Bettmann Archive/Getty Images "It was a very tumultuous and polarized time," she said in the HBO documentary. Why? Four die; one, Col. Larry Carrigan, survivesjust barely, but it is he who tells about the incident. One of the times it did, Im happy to say, was with Keith Nolan, the author of several books on the war, most recently Ripcord , a superb account of the 101st Airborne in the conflicts last great battle. In her book, she says she's a Christian. A young photographer took this harrowing image of the Vietnam War. Free shipping for many products! I mean, that's like the bank robber saying, "I'm sorry I got caught.". On this weeks edition of HBO Max and CNNs Whos Talking to Chris Wallace, the host covered much of that territory, including that 1972 visit. Some lawmakers calledher actions treason. One showed her applauding North Vietnamese anti-aircraft gunners. And it was a terrible mistake because of the image that it showed, which was not at all what the reality was. She is the daughter of legendary actor and WWII Naval Officer Henry Fonda. Politicians make mistakes that affect the body politic and statesmen sometimes direct a foreign policy that disregards individuals in the national interest. Jane Fonda was more than just an actress born to a wealthy and prominent Hollywood family. Oh, my God. One of the definitions of treason is giving aid and comfort to the enemy. Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions. I mean, the fact is, there's no statute on treason, by the way. In it, she apologizes once again for insulting the men and women who fought in Vietnam. The actual allegation took the form of an email citing the alleged experiences of a number of Viet Nam War veterans at the hands of Jane Fonda. Did we lie about the body that we planted on Omaha Beach (search), trying to convince the Germans that we were going to land somewhere else? Jane Fonda sparked outrage among war veterans when she was pictured sitting on an anti-aircraft gun in 1972 during the Vietnam War, earning her the nickname Hanoi Jane. Considering the admonition about Caesar's wife, perhaps HNN should remove you as an intern. . CHRIS WALLACE: Your most famous protest was 50 years ago when you went to North Vietnam at the height of the war there. Imagine its the Battle of the Bulge and Betty Grable is up on top of a German tank saying the Yanks are fighting an evil war. Its not a preposterous analogynot as far as the soldiers involved are concerned. Peter Braunsteins article speculated that Jane Fonda had this ability to a degree unique in modern times. Jane Fonda I will never know. Trump Jumps on Kellyanne Conway Divorce To SAVAGELY Tell World He Finds George Conway Extremely Unattractive, Republican Strategist Goes Scorched Earth on CPAC Scam, Rips Professional Grassroots Huckster Wing of the GOP, CPAC Crowd Stands and Cheers as Raging Steve Bannon Vows to Bring Down Fox News: Were Going To Fight You Every Step Of The Way!, Florida Bill Requiring Bloggers to Register with Government Wont Survive Court Challenge, Says UF Law Prof, CPAC Crowd Cheers Wildly as Matt Gaetz Demands Congress Defund Federal Law Enforcement, They Are Lying: Tucker Carlson Reveals Why He Will Air Hidden Surveillance Jan 6th Footage Next Week, Marjorie Taylor Greene, Please Just Shut the Hell Up: Michael Steele Tells Fool Congresswoman She Has No Clue, Former Federal Prosecutor Says Rupert Murdoch Agreed with The Worst Possible Sentence in His Deposition, CNN Anchor Asks Chuck Schumer If Democratic Senators Should Still Go On Fox News In Light of Dominion Revelations, DeSantis Snaps at Reporter When Pressed On What He Would Do Differently From Biden in Ukraine, End This Charade: Tim Robbins Backs Woody Harrelson Calling to End Covid Mandates, De La Soul Lives! It is always distressing to find American citizens who benefit from the protection and assistance of this government lending their voice in any way to governments such as the Democratic Republic of Vietnam distressing indeed, said State Department spokesman Charles W. Bray, according to a July 1972 Reuters story. Ramsey Clark went to Hanoi during the war. However, the fact that she advocated Communism does not give anyone license to make up stories or slander. She now hosts "New Day" on CNN. Troop B, 2nd squadron, 17th Cavalry, RVN, 1969-70 JANE FONDA: It was a terrible mistake. I was not the kind of mother that I wished I had been to my children. The charges against Fonda went beyond the notion that she was an apologist for the mistreatment of American prisoners of war. We're trained. Hardly misdirected anger, Jane Fonda really was merely a silly and shallow child of privilege who allowed herself to be used for propaganda. She called the POW's liars. JANE FONDA: Well, I didnt like it. officers, toward the Chinese border amid cries of protest from Wall Street which feared war with "our trading partner" Red China. Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions. Yeah, said my stepdaughter, Jill, when I told her about this. For example, she went on Radio Hanoi a number of times, while our troops, your friends, were being shot at by an enemy in Vietnam, saying our POWs were in good health. She went to tour the countrys And it was a terrible mistake because of the image that it showed, which was not at all what the reality was. Jane Fonda was on 3 times this week talking about her new book. After all, she is an American; surely shell carry the message home to the families that their husband or son is alive. Jane Fonda Comes Clean, Admits She Was Bad Mother: I was not The day anti-Vietnam War protesters tried to levitate the Pentagon. The alleged mission was to prevent communism from spreading to South Korea, a peninsula pointed at now disarmed Japan. It's not just handing out, you know, blankets. It was my mistake, and I have paid and continue to pay a heavy price for it. Fonda said that whileshe may have been tricked into taking the picture, The buck stops here. And I was I was like a limp noodle what I had experienced and what I had seen, I just I wasnt able to resist, they said were gonna take you out here today. She said that she regretted it. Read on. This story hearkens to a real visit to North Vietnam by Jane Fonda in July of 1972, but the stories about betraying POWs is not true. The Fonda trip became unforgettable because it infuriated Americans, especially Americans in uniform, many of whom still regard her as a traitor. Mr. Nolan wrote something that helped me better understand the fury of this sort of reaction. [3] She praised the USSR for their support of the Viet Cong. William Burkhead, a Democrat from Anne Arundel, said, I wouldnt want to kill her, but I wouldnt mind if you cut her tongue off, according to a Post story. She was reportedly also an aspirant for a role on "Fox & Friends," the network's morning show. Megyn Kelly Fact-Check: The Truth About Jane Fonda and Vietnam I wanted to tell them what I was seeing as an American on the ground there. 's and eMediaMillWorks, Inc.'s copyrights or other proprietary rights or interests in the material. Richard Morgan, Transcription Copyright 2005 eMediaMillWorks, Inc. (f/k/a Federal Document Clearing House, Inc.), which takes sole responsibility for the accuracy of the transcription. It never happened. Only the bankers know. Fifty years later, he bears witness again. YOU'VE REACHED YOUR MONTHLY ARTICLE LIMIT. Mr. Nolan wrote something that helped me better understand the fury of this sort of reaction. It evidently didnt. During the visit she posed for several pictures. Heres Kellys take on what she called Fondas poor me routine. Jane Fonda is a star of stage and screen whose career began in 1960. They have never acknowledged their role in the killing fields of Cambodia and fail to discuss the fact that Vietnam, one of about four communist countries left on the face of this earth, is currently at the bottom rung of third world nations in terms of per capita income. Libertarian commentator Jedediah Bila appeared on Fox's "Outnumbered" and later turned up on ABC's "The View.". Jane Fonda was always an outspoken opponent of the Vietnam War. HANNITY: Is Jane Fonda really sorry or just trying to sell her brand new book? There's no statute of limitations on it. Then Dr. Spock attacked the Vietnam draft. More than 58,000 Americans died in the war.. Again the secret policy of the financiers was: "containment of communism" while disallowing an American victory. I never asked pilots to desert. Watch above via HBO Max and CNNs Whos Talking to Chris Wallace. MacArthur complained that his conduct of the war was compromised by spies within the U.S. government: "The enemy receives my (Pentagon) directives before I do". He was Americas most famous pediatrician. "STRATAGEMS of DEFEAT AND NO-WIN WARS To begin with, the title is deliberately misleading: his real point has nothing to do with Jane Fonda. Why are people more angry at Jane Fonda that they are against, say, Lyndon Johnson and Richard Nixon, the people really responsible? She claimed she was sexually harassed by correspondent Brian Wilson and later spoke out against Fox News' culture after the Ailes scandal broke. It was treason, nothing more and nothing less. COLMES: She did say that she was sorry. container: 'taboola-right-rail-thumbnails', Watch "Hannity & Colmes" weeknights at 9 p.m. Look it, there were clandestine operations conducted in every war. WebDaughter of legendary Henry Fonda, actress, and activist was one of the most outspoken people against the Vietnam War at the age of 34. [1] According to a recent email that circulated to various Vietnam veterans, Fonda reportedly beat one POW, and betrayed the confidence of another, resulting in his death. I find that intolerable.. Thus, the U.S.A. deliberately betrayed its former ally Chiang Kai-Shek and gave mainland China to communism. MacArthur asked Truman to permit Chiang Kai-Shek's troops to fight with Americans against the Red Chinese. 2023 FOX News Network, LLC. [1] Cited on November 24, 2004. And I didnt even think and they sang me a song and Im made me laugh. In 1972, Fonda toured North Vietnam, where she spoke against U.S. military policy in the country. After all, she is an American; surely shell carry the message home to the families that their husband or son is alive. Liberals in America's streets "protested" our victories and exulted in our defeats - thus, in patriots' eyes, giving the war a raison d'etre. . Which is precisely why U.S. liberals so vehemently protested U.S. involvement - and that is the only reason - we were destroying their comrades the communists. One of the times it did, Im happy to say, was with Keith Nolan, the author of several books on the war, most recently Ripcord , a superb account of the 101st Airborne in the conflicts last great battle. Kelly attacked Fondas Vietnam War history to defend questions about plastic surgery. NORTH: In fact refused to apologize for the POW meeting, which was tantamount to, basically torture. According to the email she visited Hanoi in 1968. The one story that was true never touched the question of whether or not she directly participated in war crimes. Her attackers renewed an old strike against the image of an actress who grew up as the daughter of the All-American Henry Fonda, yet became synonymous with the various rebellions of the Sixties. Joe? Heres how we saw the article we ran: It is a survey of the singular career of a woman who both drove and was driven by many of the largest social concerns of her era, and who came to embody some of them. Fonda consorted with the enemy and made propaganda broadcasts on their behalf. Thank you, sir. The real story of Jane Fonda and the Vietnam vets who hate her This is a partial transcript from "Hannity & Colmes," April 6, 2005, that has been edited for clarity. The chance to remake oneself is a universally acknowledged strength of this Republic, and the Republic itself has done it often enough. Fonda wasnt deterred. It is giving them the advantage of the propaganda visibility that this woman lent to them. Jane Fonda JANE FONDA: it was a mistake to go, I never wanted to go to any military installations. Its more than being a traitor; millions of Americans felt treasonous during that war. She still does not know what she did wrong. And, as she does, each POW palms her a scrap of paper with his Social Security number written on it. The story surfaced on the Internet in 1999, and my guess is that it will live there a long time. When Rockefeller said what he said about the Cultural Revolution (in an Op Ed that I read long ago, attesting to its existence), he was addressing the Communist system as a Fascist system with potential for realizing corporate/banker control much more than as a "Marxist" system. Read more >>, The magazine was forced to suspend print publication in 2013, but a group of volunteers saved the archives and relaunched it in digital form in 2017. Someone (I dont remember who) leads me toward the gun, and I sit down, still laughing, still applauding. CHRIS WALLACE: Your most famous protest was 50 years ago when you went to North Vietnam at the height of the war there. Here's what she's got. And you were photographed sitting on an anti aircraft gun. I think so, and I would hope that all Americans will at least speak their minds at the movie box office and refuse to further enrich one of the greatest American traitors. Ms. Fonda only met with those POW's who had sold out their fellow POW's, who willingly (without torture) made propaganda statements for their captors, and who enjoyed privileges of medical care, food, and even night-time excursions into Hanoi to watch movies in return. Bates. You will not be surprised to hear that I have bowdlerised the above considerably, removing racial designators and course expressions of various sorts. Thus, Europe, Russia, China, Korea, Viet Nam, Cambodia, Thailand, Japan, the Middle East were turned into killing grounds, and their existing governments destroyed. If a prisoner tried to escape, it is quite understandable that he would probably be beaten and tortured., Also Read: How Jane Fonda Explains 'Hanoi Jane': 'Regret to My Dying Day', Even she had to apologize years later for that gun picture True. And by the way, did our government lie to us during Vietnam? Kiran Chetry was a Fox News host from 2001 to 2007. Thats all the ground troops were going home. An analogy: I'm more upset by somebody coming into my house and stealing from me than I am by a tax increase, or even by government malfeasance. Im not you know, they all went to jail. Jane Fonda Greta Van Susteren -- who had been one of Ailes' most stalwart defenders -- left in early September 2016 after saying that Fox had "not felt like a home" for years. They held signs that read Forgive? Jane Fonda Due to actions and images some people consider unpatriotic or treasonous, she earned CHRIS WALLACE: Who the people in the Nixon administration? But when you know why you did something, and youre willing to admit the mistakes that you made, but stand up for the things that you did that that mattered? Was Jane Fonda's sitting on a North Vietnamese anti-aircraft gun that was used to shoot at and kill Americans, and launching an anti-American PR campaign with the North Vietnamese giving aid and comfort? Jane Fonda It all has nothing to do with where I am sitting. As I tell my students when we discuss the proper use of testimony, we probably ought not to listen to Jane Fonda on things dealing with foreign affairs but if our goal is to rid our aging bodies from the ravages of cellulite then Fonda can be considered an authority! Jane Fonda Fast Facts ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. War materiel, shipped via the OLIVER NORTH, HOST, "WAR STORIES": Actually, she's not really apologizing. Have a tip or story idea? On the basis of those meetings alone, she proclaimed that American POW's weren't being mistreated, and that any who said they were mistreated werte either liars, or were simply experiencing punishment for their racist treatment and attitude towards their Vietnamese captors. [5] One man who was supposed to have encountered Jane Fonda, one Colonel Larry Carrigan, has denied any claim that he ever met her. Nixon has responsibility for everything he did or didn't do on his watch. Never. and booed people attending the event, according to the Frederick News-Post. Sadly, the Founders also mixed a great deal of Greco-Roman Humanism with this heritage, allowing room for much of what you decry. Ramsey Clark went to Hanoi during the war. And you know, maybe I was set up but I was an adult, its Im gonna take responsibility for it. There is certainly no doubt that the country was basically split down the middle on the idea of our military presence in SE Asia, and as Americans we were all free to protest the war to our hearts' content. Why Do People Hate Jane Fonda? Her 'Hanoi Jane' Episode, AND CHRIS WALLACE: Your most famous protest was 50 years ago when you went to North Vietnam at the height of the war there. I would like to hear more about this. You know, I have an organization in Georgia that deals with adolescents, and Ive studied parenting. HANNITY: All right. CHRIS WALLACE: When you got that nickname Hanoi Jane, how did you feel at the time? Content and Programming Copyright 2005 Fox News Network, L.L.C. There was a real Colonel Carrigan, and he was a POW in Vietnam. But Jane Fonda: Cancel my subscription!, In replying, I discovered that the Good Book notwithstanding, a soft answer turneth away wrath no more than zo percent of the time. And therein lies the difference. Deprived of American assistance, his army bereft of supplies, Chiang Kai-Shek retreated to the island sanctuary of Formosa and dug in. www.DanandGEnterprises.com Quotes displayed in real-time or delayed by at least 15 minutes. By denying their mistreatment or not investigating their treatment,in an effort to sway public opinion to her own perceived vision of the national interest, she did harm to her countrymen in captivity. Listen closely. Sheturned down a four-year, $100 million offer to stay with Fox News saying that one of the reasonsfor her departure was to spend more time with her kids. The POWs are beaten. On campus, she was pushing her movement to turn U.S. soldiers into pacifists. I dug in my heels. Here is my best, honest recollection of what took place. "Flashpoint Vietnam," the real story about the road to the war. All rights reserved. And the question I have is 50 years later, how do you look back on that particular chapter? quote: Fonda was a political activist in the counterculture era during the Why? Megyn Kelly ended her 12-year run with Fox News in early 2017 in exchange for a weekday show at NBC. One presumably claimed to have been struck by her, while another claimed to have had his confidence betrayed to his Communist captors. The Army builds a tolerance for violence, she shouted at the crowd. Thats what made me laugh. What followed was a long-lasting wave of criticism and international outrage that earned Fonda the nickname " No article of ours gets hundreds of letters, but this one did, very few of them friendly. She visited Russia in the early Sixties, and was personally impressed by the deference she received. As in Korea, communist spies within the U.S. government released vital information to the enemy. Heres a transcript of her remarks so you can judge for yourself. In 2005, she apologized again on 60 Fondas transformation from actress to activist began several years earlier. 1972: 'Hanoi' Jane--Text from CNN.com, "Vietnam: Echoes of War, Cultural Timeline" Jane Fonda -- actress, political activist and partner of anti-war Many Americans traveled to To license content, please contact licenses [at] americanheritage.com. http://www.truthminers.com/truth/hanoi_jane.htm; Biden Should Remove Cuba from List of State Sponsors of Terrorism, Descendants of Slaveholder Donor Denounce Law School Name Change, How Social Media and Community Schools Could Fill in Gaps Teaching Black History, American Girl Dolls Declare the 1990s Ancient History, Review: DeSantis's Book is a Campaign Tome Written by ChatGPT, Reconsidering Phillis Wheatley's Place in the Revolutionary Era, Philosopher Lewis Gordon's Impact on Black Jewish History, Quintard Taylor's Black Past Project Fights Erasure of History, Review: The Unfinished Business of "Double V", One Reason to Confirm National Archivist Fast? A new HBO documentary on Fondas life, Jane Fonda in Five Acts, explores the fallout for the actress, who is now 80. Hows this for a story? Now, I leave it NORTH: Well, yes, as a matter of fact I think she is. MacArthur soon realized he was expected to win battles but lose the war. tips@mediaite.com. I think that there is a lot of selectivity going on. Rudi Bakhtiar jumped from CNN to Fox News in 2006. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Fonda told Wallace that she did not like the nickname she was given, but she stuck by her choice to oppose the war. You have "War Stories" coming up. CHRIS WALLACE: When you got that nickname Hanoi Jane, how did you feel at the time? NORTH: These are the things that this woman did, and she has not apologized. Dr. Rockefeller certainly did not defend Communism as a "Jewish" system, since it is the Hebrew Bible that was the basis of our Common Law, and hence much of our Constitutional Order. So setting aside the issue of whether plastic surgery has anything to do with Vietnam, is Kelly right about Fondas record? Jane didnt make her infamous and idiotic trip to Hanoi until 1972. It meant re-taking the same bloody ground over and over again. NORTH: As a matter of fact, no. . How did we get into this war? "CHINA: Following WWII, Mao Tse-Tung, financed by the international banks, led his Chinese communists in an armed conflict against nationalist China under Generalissimo Chiang Kai-Shek, America's ally against Japan. Heres the picture that was used to shut shut down American plants, critics, and there were millions of them, called you a Hanoi Jane and said you were a traitor. JANE FONDA: it was a mistake to go, I never wanted to go to any military installations. [2] While criticizing America, she made laudatory comments about the Soviet Union. As anyone who knew or worked with me in those years knows my heart has always been with the soldiers. CHRIS WALLACE: So when you say it was a terrible mistake. Halyburton told him that the POW's had tried to debunk them even though they regarded Fonda as an unsympathetic figure. She called our POWs hypocrites and liars and referred to their torture as understandable. However, the allegation that she abused American POWs is not true. What most Viet-Nam veterans think about Jane Fonda is expressed in a number of products sold by D & G Enterprises, Respected online resources such as Snopes, Truth Miners, and Urban Legends have all cited key persons in the infamous email as having refuted its claims. And you were photographed sitting on an anti aircraft gun. Fox News has enhanced the careers of numerous women who have served as hosts. Jane Fonda You're a great American. [5]http://www.snopes.com/military/fonda.asp; http://urbanlegends.about.com/library/weekly/aa110399b.htm; http://www.truthminers.com/truth/hanoi_jane.htm; cited on November 24, 2004. Its going to look like I was trying to shoot down U.S. planes! In 1972, the Academy Award-winning actress and activist traveled to North Vietnam and was photographed laughing and clapping along with Vietnamese soldiers. How Jane Fonda Became The Most-Hated Woman Among Vietnam Jane Fonda Fonda traveled to Hanoi, Vietnam, to protest the Vietnam War, but she did not do most of the things the post claims. I have had my say. They realized that the war was wrong, that we werent wanted there. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Maybe John Nolte of Breitbart had the best of intentions, but his essay We Should Accept Jane Fondas Apology About Vietnam is an ethics mess. By July 1972, when Fonda accepted an invitation to visit North Vietnam, America had been at war overseas and with itself for years. WebIn July of 1972 Jane Fonda went to Hanoi, North Vietnam, for a two-week tour of the country. But newly discovered tapes tell a very, very different story. It wasnt firing at the time, and Fonda said in 2011 she hardly even thought about where I was sitting and that it is possible that it was a set up, that the Vietnamese It has simply been repeated over and over again, without proof, and duplicated on a number of websites. If I was used, I allowed it to happen. And exocide (ph) and biocide. She went to tour the countrys dike system, which was rumored to have been intentionally bombed by American forces something the U.S. government to this day forcefully denies. Many Americans traveled to Vietnam on peace delegations to end the war, yet it was Jane Fonda who was captured as a timeless image when she was photographed looking through a Viet Cong anti-aircraft gun.